Login / Register ID | EN
This page has no official English version. It was translated automatically and may contain errors. Read the original in Indonesian →
Investigasi Kecelakaan Kerja: Enam Kriteria SMK3 dan Tiga Lapis Penyebabnya
Foto: Pexels
Hukum Industri

Work Accident Investigation: Six Criteria of K3 Management System and Three Layers of Causes

A report within 2 x 24 hours after a workplace accident answers one question: what happened. The next question, why it happened, has its own regulations. The SMK3 auditor demands this through six criteria.

Two inspections, two owners

Article 11 of Law Number 1 of 1970 requires management to report every accident at the workplace they oversee. The procedure is regulated by Minister of Manpower Regulation Number 03/MEN/1998, which is still valid according to the JDIH Kemnaker.

This regulation separates two inspections:

  • Inspection by the supervisor. Article 6 states that every reported accident must be inspected and reviewed by labor inspectors, without exception.
  • Inspection by the company itself. This is regulated by Government Regulation Number 50 of 2012 through criterion 8.3, and this is what is assessed during the SMK3 audit.

One thing that is often overlooked: what must be reported is not only accidents that injure people. Article 2 paragraph (2) also includes fires, explosions, hazardous waste disposal, and other hazardous incidents. Article 1 number 2 defines other hazardous incidents as potential events that can cause workplace accidents or occupational diseases. Near-miss incidents are also counted. Article 4 sets a deadline for written reports of 2 x 24 hours and allows for verbal reports beforehand.

For reports to BPJS Ketenagakerjaan and the consequences of delays, see the article on phase I and phase II reports.

Six criteria demanded by auditors

Appendix II of PP 50/2012 places it in element 8, Reporting and Correcting Deficiencies:

Criterion Summary of contents Assessment starts at level
8.3.1 There are procedures for inspecting and reviewing workplace accidents and occupational diseases Initial (64 criteria)
8.3.2 Inspections are conducted by designated K3 experts or other competent and authorized parties Transition (122 criteria)
8.3.3 The report includes causes and effects, recommendations, and a schedule for corrections Continuation (166 criteria)
8.3.4 The person responsible for corrective actions has been designated Continuation
8.3.5 Corrective actions are communicated to workers at the incident site Continuation
8.3.6 Implementation is monitored, documented, and communicated to all workers Continuation

This arrangement explains a common gap. At the initial level, a company only needs to have the procedure in place. The content of the report, who will make the corrections, and whether workers are informed are only assessed at the continuation level. Thus, a neatly organized procedure in a folder can pass the initial audit, even if not a single accident has been thoroughly analyzed to its root cause. The three-tiered working method is discussed in the SMK3 audit article.

Three layers of causes

PP 50/2012 does not establish a method. One guideline that can be used is HSG245 from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), the K3 regulator in the UK. This guideline categorizes causes into three layers:

Layer Meaning according to HSG245 Example of a slippery step
Immediate cause the agent that causes injury slippery step surface
Underlying cause unsafe actions or conditions no anti-slip coating
Root cause management, planning, or organizational failures where other failures arise routine inspections never included the stairs

HSE also emphasizes that investigations concluding operator error as the sole cause are rarely acceptable. Behind human error, there are always conditions that make the error easy to occur.

Reports that stop at the first layer still meet the wording of criterion 8.3.3, because the cause is documented. However, the corrections become patchwork, and similar incidents are just waiting for their turn.

How deep: measure from the worst consequence

According to HSG245, the depth of the investigation is determined by the worst possible consequence and the likelihood of recurrence, not the injury that happened this time. For example, a scaffold collapse without casualties. The injury count is zero, but the potential for serious injury or death exists.

Investigation level Involved parties
Minimal related supervisor, seeking lessons
Low supervisor or direct superior, brief, up to three layers of causes
Medium supervisor, K3 advisor, and worker representatives
High joint team under the supervision of senior management or directors

The steps are four: gather information as soon as possible while witness memories are fresh, analyze, determine risk controls, then develop an action plan and execute it. It is the fourth step that is demanded by criteria 8.3.4 to 8.3.6.

This topic is also discussed in the Contractor Safety Management System class. If you prefer to see the explanation directly, there is a clip available.

Sources

  1. JDIH Kementerian Ketenagakerjaan, Government Regulation Number 50 of 2012 on the Implementation of the Occupational Safety and Health Management System, status Valid (Appendix II criteria 8.3 and Table 1)
  2. JDIH Kementerian Ketenagakerjaan, Minister of Manpower Regulation Number 03/MEN/1998 on Procedures for Reporting and Inspecting Accidents, status Valid (Articles 1, 2, 4, and 6)
  3. Law Number 1 of 1970 on Occupational Safety, Article 11
  4. Health and Safety Executive, HSG245: Investigating accidents and incidents, working guide for employers, trade unions, and K3 practitioners