Login / Register ID | EN
This page has no official English version. It was translated automatically and may contain errors. Read the original in Indonesian →
Temuan Major, Minor, dan Observasi: Definisi Resmi dan Akibatnya pada Sertifikasi
Foto: Pexels
Industri Bisnis

Major, Minor, and Observation Findings: Official Definitions and Their Impact on Certification

The closing audit meeting often gets stuck on one question: is this finding major or minor? The auditor says major, while the process owner claims it's just minor. The debate rarely concludes because each party uses their own criteria. In fact, the definition is written down, but it's not located in the standards typically referenced by internal auditors.

The definition is in ISO/IEC 17021-1, not ISO 19011

ISO 19011:2018, the guideline for auditing management systems, categorizes audit findings into just two: conformity and nonconformity. Article 3.21 defines nonconformity as the failure to meet a requirement. The terms major and minor are not included in its list of definitions.

The distinction between major and minor comes from ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015, the standard requirements for certification bodies of management systems. The only benchmark is: does the nonconformity affect the ability of the management system to achieve the expected results?

Category Basis Criteria
Major ISO/IEC 17021-1 Article 3.12 affects the ability of the system to achieve the expected results
Minor ISO/IEC 17021-1 Article 3.13 does not affect that ability
Observation ISO 19011 Article 3.10, Note 2 not a nonconformity; findings that indicate risks, opportunities for improvement, or good practices

Thus, what determines the impact is not the number of incorrect pages or how embarrassing the finding is in front of management.

Two conditions that elevate a finding to major

Note 1 in Article 3.12 mentions two conditions:

  1. There is significant doubt that the process controls are operating effectively, or that the products and services will meet the established requirements.
  2. A number of minor nonconformities on the same requirement or issue may indicate a systemic failure, thus counting as major.

The second condition is often overlooked. Three minor findings all related to document control, across three different departments, can be interpreted as one major. Therefore, before the closing meeting, try to group minor findings according to their clauses.

An example of measuring instruments that have missed their calibration schedule is also assessed with the same benchmark. If the measurement results are used to pass products and there are no other controls, the doubt in item 1 is fulfilled. If the calibration system is functioning and only one instrument is late, the impact is smaller.

The consequences differ during certification

Article 9.5.2 of ISO/IEC 17021-1, as quoted by European Accreditation, outlines what certification bodies must have done before making a certification decision:

Category Before the certification decision Implementation checked
Major corrections and corrective actions have been reviewed, accepted, and verified before the decision
Minor correction and corrective action plans have been reviewed and accepted generally at the next audit, such as the first surveillance
Observation no requirements have been violated, so nothing is closed monitored as a risk

This citation does not contain a single deadline applicable to all bodies. The deadline for submitting plans and evidence of corrective actions is set by each certification body in its certification rules. Check those documents before the audit, not after the findings are released.

In internal audits, the definition is self-established

Since ISO 19011 does not require the distinction between major and minor, internal audits can use any scale. Many organizations borrow the definitions from ISO/IEC 17021-1 so that their internal audit results are comparable to certification audits. What matters is that the definitions are documented in the audit procedure before the audit begins, not decided in the closing meeting.

Two other items from the ISO 19011 glossary are worth noting. Audit evidence must be verifiable (Article 3.9), so findings without recordings or verifiable factual statements are not yet suitable for classification. If the audit criteria are regulatory compliance, the findings are typically referred to as compliance or noncompliance (Article 3.7, Note 1).

The auditor's thought process behind the findings is discussed further in the ISO internal audit article, and how to select evidence samples in the internal audit sampling article. This topic is also covered in the class Audit Internal Sistem Manajemen Mutu Berbasis ISO 19011. If you prefer to see the explanation directly, there is a clip.

Sources